Struggling home-buyers and owners turning to non-bank lenders

Second-tier lenders offer struggling homeowners an alternative, helping some avoid mortgagee sales. While rates are higher, flexible lending criteria provide short-term relief. From Scoop business
November 10, 2024

Second-tier lenders are proving a useful option for some struggling home-buyers and homeowners - including those going to mortgagee sales.

"Second-tier" usually refers to non-bank lenders, such as Liberty and Pepper Money, that offer home loans and other lending. They usually charge higher interest rates but may have different lending criteria to that of the banks.

Mortgage adviser Karen Tatterson, from Loan Market, said it was common that people facing a mortgagee sale would look for help from a second-tier lender instead.

"Many times the owners leave the investigation via a mortgage adviser too late in the process. This results in the property being listed and then cancelled once second tier lending has been approved."

Barfoot & Thompson said about 15 percent of mortgagee sales were stopped because agreements had been made for the owner to keep the property or there was a court injunction.

Tatterson said opting for a non-bank lender was only a short-term solution for many but enables them to hold onto their home.

Usually after a short period - minimum of six months - the home loan is refinanced from the second tier lender back to a main bank.

Liberty is advertising a floating rate of 8.15 percent, a two-year rate of 7.75 percent and a one-year rate of 8.05 percent.

That compares to 7.39 percent floating at ASB, 5.49 percent for two years and 5.79 percent for one.

Key Mortgages adviser Jeremy Andrews said he had done more second-tier lending over the last six months than ever before.

"Typically second tier lending is priced as floating with options of fixed rates typically fewer and less attractive, so this might be off putting in a rising interest rate market. But this is more attractive right now while in a falling interest rates market.

"Some advantages of second tier lenders are they can consider out of the box incomes and scenarios. Sometimes clients with strong equity can borrow and 'capitalise' their interest costs (have these added onto the loan) without being able to technically service the loan in the short term. This typically requires an 'exit strategy' such as selling the property in the short to medium term or other funds or steady income to be coming later."

He said there could be fees associated with the lender ranging from a few hundred dollars to thousands, or sometimes 2 percent or 3 percent of the total loan value.

"With main bank timeframes stretching out last year to often weeks turnaround times, second tiers can sometimes approve lending much quicker too."

He said the last three second-tier loans he organised were all at rates below 8 percent but they would increase as the borrower's rick profile did.

Reserve Bank data shows the amount of housing lending by non-bank institutions has dropped from $6.05 billion in November 2022 to $5.4b in November last year. It appears to fluctuate - dropping to $5.015b in November 2023 then picking up to $5.78b in July last year.

Squirrel chief executive David Cunningham said mortgagee sales were still so infrequent that he had not seen any.

He said it was a small part of the market because banks did a good job and were price-competitive.

"The non-bank lenders need a bigger margin to cover wholesale funding costs. So they get the 'dregs' - often good quality but a bit outside the square."

Latest News

February 19, 2026
ASB joins low deposit Kāinga Ora scheme with big benefits
This is some text inside of a div block.

Key Mortgages shares details with Good Returns how expanded low-deposit lending options may help eligible first home buyers enter the market sooner and with better pricing

Read Article
February 13, 2026
Buying a house with friends or family? Watch out
This is some text inside of a div block.

As featured in Stuff, buying property with friends or family can improve affordability, but clear agreements and proper structure are essential.

Read Article
December 23, 2025
Why home loan applicants might face an extra wait
This is some text inside of a div block.

Banks and Mortgages advisers discuss with New Zealand Herald, why home loan approvals may take longer as lenders apply more detailed affordability checks and tighter financial assessments.

Read Article
January 13, 2026
How old is too old for a home loan?
This is some text inside of a div block.

In our recent discussion with Radio New Zealand, we shared that age alone doesn't prevent home loan approval, but lenders carefully assess retirement income and long-term repayment plans.

Read Article
October 8, 2025
10 Years of Trusted Mortgage Advice - Standing by Clients as Banks Change the Rules
This is some text inside of a div block.

Key Mortgages has been committed to supporting clients for nearly a decade, offering ongoing advice and tailored solutions without extra fees, even as industry changes occur.‍

Read Article
December 22, 2025
Couple lose home loan complaint in face of $50,000 break fee
This is some text inside of a div block.

Jeremy from Key Mortgages shares experiences of fixing in high rates long term and using break fee benefit calculator. One couple’s complaint over costly break fees after fixing five-year mortgage at 6.29%–6.66% rejected.

Read Article